10,000 Bullets   Exploring the world of Cinema from the Arthouse to the Grindhouse™




Magnificent Butcher :Comparison (Hong Kong Legends vs. Fox) 
Written by: on September 24th, 2004
Theatrical Release Date: Hong Kong, 1979
Director: Woo-ping Yuen
Writer: Jing Wong
Cast: Sammo Hung Kam-Bo , Biao Yuen, Hoi San Lee
magnificent butcher
magnificent butcher
DVD released: 2001 2003
Approximate running time: 104 minutes 108 minutes
Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1 Anamorphic Widescreen 2.35:1 Anamorphic Widescreen
Rating: 18 PG 13
Sound: Dolby Digital stereo English and Cantonese Dolby Digital 5.1 English, Mandarin and Cantonese
DVD Release: Hong Kong Legends Fox
Region Coding: Region 2 Pal Region 1 NTSC
Retail Price: $22.95 $9.98

Hong Kong Legends Region 2 DVD
Fox ‘s Region 1 DVD


The Film :

Butcher Wing is the inept student of Wong Fei Hung who accidentally assaults an innocent man a bad blood brews between him and a rival martial school led by Master Kao. Enter Wing’s long lost brother who has just arrived in town with his wife who is kidnapped by Master Kou’s son, Tai Ho. Wing’s brother teams up with a drunken master who helps him get his wife back. Through a series of events butcher Wing will be framed for murder.

Video:

Both Fox’s and Hong Kong Legend’s releases of the Magnificent Butcher retain the films original aspect ratio. The colors and flesh tones are very good on both releases. Fox’s release just slightly better with shaper picture and overall detail through out. Both releases are free or artifacts and grain is kept to a minimum. My only major complaint is with Hong Kong Legend’s release which suffers from over scan.

Audio:

Fox’s Release comes with the original Cantonese and Mandarin audio tracks and an English dubbed track in Dolby Digital 5.1 and the Hong Kong Legends release comes with the original Cantonese audio and an English dubbed track in Dolby Digital stereo. All the audio tracks included on these releases are free of distortion or hiss with the slight edge going to Fox’s releases which has a fuller audio overall. Both Fox and Hong Kong Legends have included subtitles on their releases and here is where the DVD’s are drastically different. The Fox release contains subtitles that have been taken from the English dubbed track. While the Hong Kong Legends release comes with subtitles that are more faithful to what is actually being said on the Cantonese track. Hong Kong Legends release gets the slight edge for included more accurate subtitles.

Extras:

Fox’s release includes the following extras the films original trailer and trailers for some of Fox’s other Hong Kong releases. Other extras include production notes, original promotion materials, amazing Sammo Hung music video, movie photo gallery, Sammo Hung and Yuen Woo-ping photo galleries and biographies. Hong Kong Legends release includes the following extras the UK and original theatrical trailers, biographies for Sammo Hung and Yuen Woo-ping and trailers for other Hong Kong Legends releases. Rounding out the extras is an audio commentary with Hong Kong film expert Ben Logan and interviews with Sammo Hung and Yuen Woo-ping. Hong Kong Legends release is hands down the better of the two releases in the extras department.

Overall:

Both releases are very good with pros and cons in favor of each, still in the end the better of the two releases is obviously Hong Kong Legends releases which comes with a wealth of extras and accurate English subtitles.

Disclaimer: Some of the reviews contained here at 10kbullets contain screenshots that may not be suitable for those surfing the website at work and discretion is advised while viewing these pages. All of the screenshots and other images used on this site are solely for promotional purposes and are copyrighted to their respective owners. All reviews, bios and interviews unless noted in the text of the review, bio or interview are original content that was written exclusively for 10kbullets and has never been published anywhere else. On occasion there may be typos or errors in the text and if you let us know we will be more then happy to correct all typos or misinformation in the text. All opinions expressed on this site are solely those of the author(s) and not that of any company or person referred to. All the written material contained on 10kBullets is intended for informational purposes only and it is copyright © 2004-Present by the authors.